Orbital Environment
Comment
Stakeholder Type

Orbital Environment

Our local region of space offers significant untapped resources: an unrivalled view of Earth, almost unlimited solar power, a high-quality vacuum and microgravity in abundance. For the more ambitious, there is the Moon, Mars and various near-Earth asteroids. Between them, these offer water ice, metals, building materials and real estate.

Video

Are we ready to cross a new frontier and live in space?

    Earth orbit and rocky bodies are also potential human habitats. NASA’s Artemis programme, which will send humans to the Moon potentially as early as 2026, will eventually create a lunar base.1 China has similar plans, with the initial phase involving the creation of a scientific facility in the Moon’s south polar region by 2035.2 In the longer term, Mars could also become a human habitat.

    Wherever humans go, they will need power and the capability to build the things they need using local resources in exotic environments. Near-Earth asteroids offer potentially valuable resources for those able to make use of them. Space-based manufacturing techniques will need to evolve to make full use of these resources.

    Closer to home, Earth orbits themselves are another resource. The future of the International Space Station is a topic of much debate and uncertainty. NASA currently plans to begin de-orbiting the station in 20303 but another option is for a commercial operator to build on the station carcass to create a larger, more capable facility.

    The advent of commercial launch services is making access to low Earth orbit cheaper and easier. Companies like Sierra Space, Blue Origin and Axiom Space are developing their own space stations offering facilities for research, manufacturing, drug development and so on.

    One important cargo will be paying visitors. Space tourism is a well-established business, albeit on a limited scale. That looks set to accelerate, with operators such as SpaceX, Virgin Galactic and Blue Origin offering paid seats on flights. The future of human space flight is highly dependent on ensuring passenger safety, however.

    All this activity is making orbital real estate an increasingly crowded and valuable resource. So the way the industry maintains safety and deals with accidents will have a crucial impact on growth.

    However these fields evolve, the orbital environment will need to be protected, perhaps in the same way as other global commons, such as the oceans or Antarctica.4 That will require formal global coordination, governance and an appropriate legal framework.

    In the 1960s, the space race was driven by geopolitical tensions and played out as a proxy for war. An important question today is how relations between global superpowers will shape the next generation of space exploration, given that the difference between friendly cooperation and antagonistic rivalry is likely to be profound.

    KEY TAKEAWAYS

    The regions beyond Earth contain a plethora of resources that would be of value both on Earth and in pursuit of human goals in terrestrial orbit and beyond. Harvestable Extraterrestrial resources include valuable minerals and resources for fuel, construction and sustenance for space-based communities, as well as solar energy. The Orbital region itself is also proving valuable as real estate, hosting ever more satellites that have increasing commercial and military significance. An area ripe for development is Space manufacturing, which could significantly reduce the cost and difficulty of space exploration and habitation, as well as providing means to manufacture items that are difficult or impossible to manufacture on Earth. The field of Satellite innovation is seeing significant progress, with an increasing number of agencies working on the ability to manoeuvre one satellite to inspect, refuel or even disable another. Some researchers in the field have expressed concern about the geopolitical implications of such developments.

    Emerging Topic:

    Anticipation Potential

    Orbital Environment

    Sub-Fields:

    Extraterrestrial resources
    Orbital region
    Space manufacturing
    Satellite innovation
    Earth’s Orbital region is the domain requiring the most global multilateral attention, given issues around the management of space debris and the proliferation of satellites and other orbiting objects. The exploitation of Extraterrestrial resources still requires sustained investments, research and technological development over the coming 20 years. Major advances will occur with relative certainty along the way, but the field will require strong, coordinated international action.

    Anticipatory Impact:

    Three fundamental questions guide GESDA’s mission and drive its work: Who are we, as humans? How can we all live together? How can we ensure the well-being of humankind and the sustainable future of our planet? We asked researchers from the field to anticipate what impact future breakthroughs could have on each of these dimensions. This wheel summarises their opinions when considering each of these questions, with a higher score indicating high anticipated impact, and vice versa.

    • Anticipated impact on who we are as humans
    • Anticipated impact on how we will all live together
    • Anticipated impact on the well-being of humankind and sustainable future of our planet

    Extraterrestrial resources

    The resources available in space divide broadly into two categories: those that can be used to support in-space activities and those that can eventually be brought back to Earth.

    Future Horizons:

    ×××

    5-yearhorizon

    Moon landings trigger public debate on lunar resources

    Decommissioning the International Space Station encourages competition among companies from the US, Japan and China to offer research and manufacturing facilities in orbit. NASA’s Artemis programme and commercial landers increase global interest in the Moon, with missions demonstrating the first extraction of water and metals from the lunar surface. This work drives an international debate on how best to make use of the Moon’s resources and to spread the benefits across all humanity while preserving the lunar environment for future generations.

    10-yearhorizon

    In-orbit manufacturing comes of age

    Space-based manufacturing becomes possible7 with the growing resources available at space stations in low Earth orbit. The first demonstrations of continuous transmission of solar power from orbit to Earth provide valuable momentum for net-zero efforts, driven particularly by countries like Japan that have limited terrestrial resources of their own. But the cost of the enterprise raises questions about the ability to scale production to levels that will have significant impact.

    25-yearhorizon

    The Moon becomes the gateway to the solar system

    Lunar mining facilities begin to continuously produce propellant, metals and building materials on a usable scale. This paves the way for a lunar base that is a self-supporting manufacturing facility for beyond-Earth space exploration. At the same time, lunar orbiting facilities such as space stations become key hubs in the networks of travel, manufacturing and tourism. Much of this is enabled by a lunar communication network and formal lunar governance and policy developed by international diplomacy.

    5 Most of the near-term opportunities involve using resources in situ, with Moon exploration set to become a significant driver of science and technology in this area.

    Operating on the Moon will require locally produced resources, such as water extracted from ice at the lunar poles. This can be broken down into oxygen and hydrogen for propellant and life support, and the first pilot mission to demonstrate this capability will be an important milestone. Characterising the make-up of the regolith and the ice it contains will be an important early goal for these missions.

    Near-Earth asteroids are a more distant potential source of precious metals, ores and ices. But the huge cost of such missions is a significant stumbling block.

    In 2023, the Space Solar Power Demonstrator (SSPD-1) satellite demonstrated that solar power could be harvested in space and beamed to Earth in the form of microwaves. Future challenges include expanding panels to the kilometre scale.6

    A different kind of resource is found on the far side of the Moon: a unique radio silence that astronomers hope will give them access to clear signals from elsewhere in the universe.

    Extraterrestrial resources - Anticipation Scores

    Orbital region

    The orbital region around Earth is a resource of growing importance and strategic value, largely because cheap commercial launchers have made access easier.

    Future Horizons:

    ×××

    5-yearhorizon

    In-orbit debris removal begins

    Moving defunct spacecraft and deorbiting other large pieces of debris becomes common as commercial vehicles with these capabilities become available. But a lack of transparency over what objects are being moved where increases calls for a move towards global governance of space commons.

    10-yearhorizon

    Debate over space weapons heats up

    Commercial activities in facilitating launch and returning objects like small pieces of debris from space dramatically increase the cadence of operations in orbit. Spaceplanes, space tugs and “free flyers” are commonplace.

    25-yearhorizon

    Space traffic control gets green light

    The world’s space traffic control begins operating from Rwanda (a legacy of the Rwandan Space Agency’s long-standing role in space diplomacy). This real-time service coordinates on-demand launches to all destinations.

    Humanity uses this environment as a viewing platform from which it can observe the Earth and the universe, as a thoroughfare for spacecraft, and as a home for satellites. Satellites provide commercial services such as telecommunications and Earth observation, civic services such as climate studies, and weather-monitoring and military services such as intelligence-gathering and both offensive and defensive operations.

    Nation states have already begun to increase resources devoted to protecting, inspecting and destroying assets in space.8 The weaponisation of space is increasing tensions and raising the stakes for space-related diplomacy.9

    Overcrowding is likely to become an important issue, particularly in areas of special interest, such as Lagrange points and low Earth orbit. But the prospects of “Kessler Syndrome”, in which a chain reaction of collisions increases debris levels exponentially, will drop as operators remove the large pieces of debris, like defunct satellites and spent rocket stages, that are the greatest threat. Various companies and agencies are already developing debris-removal capabilities. Space tugs that can move satellites have already been demonstrated, and the European Space Agency plans to demonstrate the safe removal of a large piece of debris with its Clearspace-1 satellite,10 due for launch in 2026.

    How this orbital hygiene will be organised is not clear, but there are calls for a better form of space traffic control to reduce the chance of accidents, for the planned clean-up of space debris and for an appropriate legal environment to resolve disputes.

    Orbital region - Anticipation Scores

    Space manufacturing

    Earth orbit is a region of microgravity, high-vacuum conditions and clean energy from the Sun. As such, it offers manufacturing industry a site that is conducive to producing high-purity components, experimenting with exotic manufacturing methods and even attempting to create substances that cannot be made on Earth.

    Future Horizons:

    ×××

    5-yearhorizon

    Power boost for space manufacturing

    The in-orbit construction of a replacement for the International Space Station and stations for Japan and China boosts manufacturing capabilities in low Earth orbit. The availability of kilowatt power systems in orbit and on the Moon kick-starts research and development of microgravity and low-gravity manufacturing techniques. This allows the prototyping of products and materials that are commercially viable.

    10-yearhorizon

    Construction of a new International Space Station begins

    With a clear business case for commercially viable materials, space manufacturing begins to scale up, aided by the construction of a kilometre-scale array to harvest solar power.

    25-yearhorizon

    Lunar habitation approaches feasibility

    Moon- and Mars-based manufacturing of building materials, propellant and oxygen for life support leads to the prospect of self-supporting lunar habitation. Megawatt power supplies unlock a wide range of opportunities for lunar and orbital manufacturing, allowing space manufacturing to enter the supply chain.

    For example, these conditions ought to allow for higher-quality versions of pharmaceuticals, metals or semiconductors that can outperform those made on Earth.11 That should mean that large spare-part inventories for space-based operations will become a thing of the past.

    The most important manufacturing limitation is the availability of power. A key enabler will be the availability of larger power sources both in orbit and on the Moon. Kilowatt power sources are expected in the next two to three years, but megawatts are needed for industrial-scale production. Finding ways to establish these is an important goal for space agencies and commercial operators such as Blue Origin.

    Larger power systems will enable the manufacture and construction of bigger structures like remote sensing antennas, the building blocks for human habitation modules and semiconductor fabrication.

    The longer-term goal is to find ways to make use of resources on Mars and near-Earth asteroids, which may be accelerated by construction of a Moon base or the use of lunar water ice, which can be readily turned into oxygen and hydrogen for propulsion and life support.

    Space manufacturing - Anticipation Scores

    Satellite innovation

    Giant networks of communications satellites are already a reality, with constellations belonging to SpaceX’s Starlink, Amazon’s Project Kuiper and Eutelsat OneWeb already in orbit and with others planned.

    Future Horizons:

    ×××

    5-yearhorizon

    Satellite internet services become global

    The competition among commercial companies to offer satellite broadband internet connections drives down the cost of connection and helps solve the long-standing problem of providing rural internet access, particularly in developing countries. International standards agreed for de-orbiting spacecraft at the end of their life. Safe communication with ground systems such as drones becomes common.

    10-yearhorizon

    Satellite operations have geo-political impact

    The geopolitical implications of satellite operations help drive innovation and focus efforts to govern and coordinate operations on an international level. Higher-resolution Earth observation becomes more capable and significantly cheaper.

    25-yearhorizon

    Improved satellite manoeuvrability

    Low Earth orbit becomes an attractive location for data centres because of the availability of cheap power and free cooling. However, international tensions over the deployment of space weapons and unauthorised interference with satellites raises the risk of Earth orbit becoming a region of warfare. Lunar operations lead to international standards for coordinate systems for timing, communications and above all safety. The establishment of these standards provides a foundation for a globally representative lunar community.

    These fleets will quickly become more capable as companies deploy satellite-to-satellite encrypted laser communications. Real-time video feeds from space are also gaining in popularity.12

    With launch costs dropping, satellite operators are experimenting with off-the-self components for imaging, sensing and communicating at lower cost.

    One important limit on satellite lifetime is the amount of onboard fuel. With high-end satellites costing hundreds of millions, refuelling is an attractive way to extend lifetimes. Lockheed Martin13 and Northrop Grumman14 are among companies developing a standard refuelling capability for satellites. Orbit Fab has already tested liquid pumping technology aboard the International Space Station and plans to offer satellite-refuelling services in 2025.15 This will require greater manoeuvrability: changing orbits and rendezvousing with other craft remains difficult, requiring plentiful fuel and agile propulsion systems.16

    However, the US, Russia and China are perfecting this technique in spacecraft that can approach and inspect other vehicles.17 This, is already enabling applications such as automated refuelling of spacecraft and dramatic increases in operational lifetimes. It also raises security concerns, as close approaches in orbit enable the disruption or even disabling of civil and military satellites.

    The increased activity on the Moon and in lunar orbit will require a lunar time zone with satellites proving timing, positioning and communications. That will require significant collaboration to develop international standards

    Satellite innovation - Anticipation Scores